Tue, 28 May 2019

Brazil Supreme Court's Attempt to Silence Critics Draws Fire

Voice of America
17 Apr 2019, 16:09 GMT+10

BRASILIA, BRAZIL - Brazils Supreme Court drew fire Tuesday for silencing its critics with a confidential criminal case targeting the press, pundits on social media and even a retired Army general close to President Jair Bolsonaro.

Chief Justice Jose Antonio Dias Toffoli opened the investigation last month into misinformation, slander and threats affecting the honor and security of the top court, according to court documents seen by Reuters.

On Monday, the court ordered news website O Antagonista and associated magazine Crusoe to withdraw a story published Friday that alleged a link between Toffoli and players in a long-running graft scandal.

Police on Tuesday executed search and seizure warrants issued by the court targeting outspoken critics on social media such as former cavalry officer Paulo Chagas, who campaigned with Bolsonaro last year and called the Supreme Court soft on graft.

The case is under seal and the court declined to comment.

Court adds to skepticism

After five years of corruption investigations that have jailed former presidents and billionaire business leaders, the controversy over the Supreme Courts actions added to skepticism about even Brazils most prestigious institutions.

The courts offensive drew immediate blowback from newspaper editorials, prosecutors and, indirectly, Bolsonaro himself.

Newspaper O Globo said in a Tuesday editorial that the order to take down the Antagonista/Crusoe story was of a seriousness without precedents in democratic times.

Brazils top prosecutor, Raquel Dodge, told the court she was closing the investigation opened by Toffoli on the grounds that the Supreme Court could not both investigate and judge a criminal case.

President weighs in

Bolsonaro posted a message to Twitter on Tuesday defending freedom of expression.

I believe in Brazil and its institutions and I respect the autonomy of the (branches of government), as written in our Constitution. They are indispensable principles for a democracy.

That said, my position will always be in favor of freedom of expression, a legitimate and inviolable right, he wrote.

More Brazil News

Access More

Sign up for Rio de Janeiro News

a daily newsletter full of things to discuss over drinks.and the great thing is that it's on the house!